Bagelmania

Delicious bagels (my go-to is the Black Russian). My toddler chants "Bagels! Bagels!" the whole way there and home.

I've only had their bagels, though they offer a wide variety of other bagel-related sandwiches, soups, etc, but I absolutely LOVE their lox spread on any bagel type there (and there are many options). If I'm in the mood for something sweeter, well I just recently discovered their honey butter cream cheese on a toasted blueberry bagel. Holy cow, that thing is tasty!

Favorite place in Newark to buy bagels. Excellent selection (as well as the monthly special flavor) and the staff are fantastic! Really good selection of coffees and pastries/muffins for anyone looking for something other than bagels (but really: get the bagels!).

Best bagel shop in town! A wide array of exciting flavors of bagels are made fresh daily, and the topping and sandwich options are numerous. The coffee is good as well. If that's not enough reason to love Bagelmania, you should also know that they are quick to support local charities and social events with donations. Top notch all around!

The ONLY place we have found so far that has bagels exactly like in North Jersey. They were made to perfection, fresh, and always has a good variety of them available. Highly recommend this place.

Stopped in recently to get bagels to go with cream cheese on the side. When we got home, I found a hair and bug in my cream cheese. The two ladies are very nice, but I won't go back as I don't want a food born illness.

I love this bagel shop. I have to drive 20+ miles to get to it but it's worth it. The bagel places near me are not as good. When i lived closer I'd get a bakers dozen all the time. After I moved I stopped, it was just too far. I bought some bagels just recently and they're just as I remembered them several years ago. Would love if you guys started a second Bagelmania in PA!

Bagels are very good, and the reason im not giving less stars. But the breakfast sandwich, definitely not a place to go for a good breakfast sandwich. I wouldn't have ordered one had I known they serve microwaved egg and precooked microwaved bacon, and i seriously mean microwave cooked eggs, not reheated in microwave. The egg was thick, airy, and blown out with thay greenish color in the middle you get when you cook a raw egg on high in the microwave. But the bagels were good & a nice atmosphere, but seriously microwaved eggs from a breakfast bagel shop?

Best bagel ive had since I lived in long island. Support small business, these people are dedicated hard workers.
I hate to see how empty it is after daddy gubment shut everything down for little to no reason.

Do your part. I tell everyone to go there and I advise you to do the same. Try the strawberry cream cheese 😋

Holy moly! I never knew why people from the north rave about their bagels, but this place made me finally understand. I got the Lox on a toasted onion bagel. Most places are stingy with the salmon and Bagelmania has heaps of it with thinly sliced purple onions and tomatoes and a sprinkle of capers. Plus it was the perfect amount of cream cheese too- not pouring out of the sides. I will absolutely be coming back and recommend it 100%!! By the way, lots of good coffee choices and reasonably priced.