Cayucos Candy Counter

I got an amazing decaf affogato with dark chocolate gelato. The staff was very friendly and helpful. They do require masks, but I didn't mind after receiving my delicious creation and excellent customer service.

Yummy ice cream with a large selection of flavors (including gelato). Friendly staff. This is one of my kids favorite places to stop when in Cayucos.

Very busy place, very expensive place. It cost me $8 for 2 pieces of almond toffee.

Cayucos Candy Counter has a great selection of taffy, jelly beans, Haribo, etc. I felt like a kid again. The Honey Lavender and Coppa Mista Gelato was amazing. The chocolate straw that came with the Gelato was so tasty we wanted more. Great family owned busy following all the rules in a difficult time. Is always on our list of must visits when we are nearby.

My wife took my three daughters in for ice cream. They were in wetsuits, which they showered off all the sand and dried them as much as possible before going in. One of the workers rudely said "we can't have that in here!" We go do Duckies next door very often and they never complain about people coming in with sand on their feet or slightly wet. If your business is at the beach, you should probably be a little more graceful to people coming in to SPEND MONEY at your establishment!!!!

I just purchased a coconut & chocolate candy which had turned bad (hard and discolored) before its "best by" date (in 10 days) and they were unwilling to exchange or refund it.
It is clear that customer service is lost on them and I will never visit this shop again.
As I write this, the cashier came out and stated that after calling her boss she was willing to exchange it... she probably figured out I was writing this review.
The exchange was made for one with a date in January... much better.

Great ice cream! I did not try the candy, but I have heard very good things about it. They are pretty strict on sand and water in their store, and I saw someone get kicked out for dripping a little bit.

25$ for a pound of chocolate= 7 pieces. They were extremely hard that my jaw actually popped trying to take a bite and then i quit trying. However the hard candy was a good price and my husband loved the sour selection.

Ice cream and gelato are delicious. Employees were pretty rude even tho we were first timers, not too kid friendly but its a candy store.

The staff is very friendly, even when dealing with stressful crowds. It's a wonderful place just off the coast to stop by for ice cream, some chocolates and truffles, or a small candy.